Skittles or M&Ms?

  Skittles 50%, M%Ms 50%

Pumpkin Pie or Apple Pie?

  Pumpkin Pie 50%, Apple Pie 50%

Witches or Vampires?

  Witches 48.4%, Vampires 51.6%

Candy Corn or Tootsie Rolls?

  Candy Corn 62.5%, Tootsie Rolls 37.5%

Halloween or Thanksgiving?

  Halloween 71.9%, Thanksgiving 28.1%

Ravens or Black Cats?

  Ravens 28.1%, Black Cats 71.9%

Fruits or Vegetables?

  Fruits 87.5%, Vegetables 12.5%

Go Trick or Treating or Give Out Candy?

  Trick or Treating 87.5%, Give Out Candy 12.5%

Bats or Spiders?

  Bats 93.8%, Spiders 6.2%

Scary Stories or Horror Movies?

  Scary Stories 37.5%, Horror Movies 62.5%

Cites:

https://lol.fandom.com/wiki/This_or_That