Real Tree or Fake Tree?

  Real 54.3%, Fake 45.7%

Hot Chocolate or Eggnog?

  Hot Chocolate 74.3%, Eggnog 25.7%

Ugly Sweater or Matching PJs?

  Ugly Sweater 25.75%, Matching PJs 74.3%

Sledding or Ice Skating?

  Sledding 48.6%, Ice Skating 48.6%

Gingerbread Cookies or Sugar Cookies?

  Gingerbread 26.5%, Sugar 73.5%

Gloves or Mittens?

  Gloves 76.5%, Mittens 23.5%

Black Friday or Cyber Monday?

  Black Friday 68.6%, Cyber Monday 31.4%

Sleeping Beauty or The Little Mermaid?

  Sleeping Beauty 48.5%, The Little Mermaid 51.5%

Giving or Receiving?

  Giving 61.8%, Receiving 38.2%

Grinch or Elf?

  Grinch 65.7%, Elf 34.3%

Cites:

https://lol.fandom.com/wiki/This_or_That